GALESBURG — A man shot and killed by Bloomington police earlier this month is the man believed to have robbed a Galesburg bank in 2006.
Robert E. Sylvester, 57, of Bloomington died of multiple gunshot wounds to the head and lower extremities Jan. 5 at BroMenn Regional Medical Center in Normal. He was shot by Bloomington police on Interstate 55 after leading a chase.
Sylvester was suspected in the robbery of a Check ’n Go in Bloomington, along with five other robberies in December.
Around 3 p.m. Oct. 4, 2006, Galesburg police say a white male entered the front doors of First Financial Plaza at 1865 N. Henderson St., then entered the Associated Bank and handed a teller a note demanding money. They said he did not display a weapon and did not imply he had one.
After receiving an estimated $5,000, the suspect exited the bank and left the plaza via the east-facing rear doors. He left in a white SUV, according to reports.
Bank surveillance photos were circulated to the media at the time of the robbery.
Following the incident, police received several leads, but no suspect was ever caught.
Not until, that is, Sylvester’s photograph surfaced in local newspapers following his death.
According to a police report, people recognized Sylvester as possibly the Associated Bank robber in photos of him exiting a dark-colored SUV taken by a photographer from The Pantagraph.
“We looked at photos after the Bloomington shooting (and) did some work with them on the computer,” said Lt. Rodney Riggs of the Galesburg Police Department. “We consider him the suspect that did the bank robbery at that time.”
The Galesburg Police Department contacted Bloomington police, who provided them with an old booking photo of Sylvester. Transparency overlays using the old booking photos, along with still shots from the 2006 Galesburg robbery, showed a match.
Sylvester had been an ironworker with Iron Workers International Local 112, based in East Peoria, since 2003 and was a member with a different chapter in Chicago since 2000.
Sylvester’s criminal history stretches back to 1996 in McLean County. He was arrested for a DUI that year and faced several separate traffic charges in the dozen years since then.
He also was convicted of misdemeanor and felony domestic battery and was still on probation the day he died for a 2007 felony case that included charges of unlawful use of a weapon by a felon and aggravated battery.
In April 2008, he was sentenced as part of a plea deal in that case to 39 days of periodic imprisonment, 12 months of intensive probation, 18 months of probation, 130 hours of public service and 150 days in jail, which was stayed pending his compliance with probation.
“Sometimes, you have a picture, but it’s not easy to match that picture to a person,” Riggs said, as was the case with the original surveillance photos. “Sometimes, those things shake loose.
Myself, looking at it and what they did with it (the photo), I would say it was him. It’s a pretty good match.”
Galesburg police now consider the Associated Bank case closed.

