MOSCOW — A Moscow court freed three alleged accomplices to the murder of a prominent journalist and Kremlin critic Thursday, ending a trial that further tainted the reputation of Russia’s criminal-justice system.
A jury took two hours to acquit two Chechens and a former police officer who were charged with tracking journalist Anna Politkovskaya from a supermarket to her Moscow apartment block two years ago, where a gunman shot her to death in an elevator. Prosecutors said they will appeal, and Ms. Politkovskaya’s newspaper colleagues said they will redouble their own investigation into her killing.
The verdict is an enormous setback to prosecutors and human-rights crusaders who hoped that Russia’s court system could bring the killers to justice. The death of Ms. Politkovskaya, whose reporting on Russian atrocities in Chechnya won her a slew of international awards along with a host of enemies, cemented Moscow’s reputation as a world capital of high-profile, politically tinged murders, few of which have been solved.
“I have a feeling of unbelievable shame,” said Vsevolod Bogdanov, head of Russia’s Union of Journalists, after the verdict. Gennady Gudkov, head of the security committee in Russia’s parliament, said the verdict “portrays in the worst possible way the reputation of the government, not to mention the security services.”
Stung by international outcry, the Kremlin said it ordered a thorough investigation into the killing. But Ms. Politkovskaya’s colleagues said the hunt was marred from the start by Russia’s security services, saying they stonewalled investigators and leaked bits of information that allowed some suspects to escape. Russia’s security services said they cooperated with the investigation.
Police never arrested a mastermind for the killing, and the alleged triggerman, Rustam Makhmudov, fled Moscow and is now living in Europe, according to officials. The three men who stood trial were relatively minor players who allegedly determined Ms. Politikovskaya’s whereabouts and guided the killer to her door.
Prosecutors presented mobile-phone records in court to show the brothers, Dzhabrail and Ibragim Makhmudov, were in the vicinity of Ms. Polikovskaya’s apartment at the time of the killing. Dzhabrail Makhmudov was accused of driving his brother, Rustam Makhmudov, to the building. Prosecutors said Ibragim Makhmudov warned of Ms. Politkovskaya’s impending arrival with a phone call.
The former police officer, Sergei Khadzhikurbanov, allegedly planned details of the attack, recruited the brothers and supplied them with a pistol with a silencer.
The trial was in many ways a reminder of the deficiencies of Russia’s court system, which remains largely unreformed since Soviet times despite years of Kremlin promises to bring the rule of law to Russia. Rules of evidence are fuzzy and jurors, often suspicious of what prosecutors try to tell them, are inclined to acquit defendants far more than judges.
The defendants’ lawyer, Murad Musayev, argued prosecutors came nowhere near proving their clients’ guilt. In final arguments Tuesday, Mr. Musayev accused the prosecution of fabricating evidence and dismissed their case as “dust, fluff and ash.”
After the verdict, Ms. Politkovskaya’s colleagues praised the openness of the trial but said prosecutors were hurt by the lack of cooperation from Russia’s successor to the KGB, the Federal Security Service.
A former FSB agent, Pavel Ryaguzov, wasn’t directly accused of being part of the murder but was accused of extortion in another aspect of the case and sat throughout the trial in a cage in the courtroom with the defendants.
Sergei Sokolov, chief editor of Ms. Politkovskaya’s newspaper, Novaya Gazeta, said that authorities never made a proper search of Mr. Ryaguzov’s office. He said the FSB also refused to hand over information that could have been crucial to the case, such as telephone wiretaps of people connected to the suspects. “I think that if the investigators were allowed to work effectively, then we would have seen different results,” he said.
Write to Alan Cullison at alan.cullison@wsj.com



